If you’re the type of discerning customer who checks out Yelp before trying a new place, you’ll be blown away by the reviews for Bi-Rite Creamery. There are more than 9,000 of them—a bit above your average review count for an ice cream shop.

The wild popularity of this ice cream shop can be credited to the ingenuity of its founders, who use locally sourced, seasonally ingredients to design new ice cream flavors all the time. Some of their confections are year-round staples, however, like the fan favorite, honey lavender. Regulars also sing the praises of the balsamic strawberry and the roasted banana ice creams. Try one of these beloved treats or stop by Bi-Rite Creamery to sample a newly unveiled seasonal ice cream.