Wednesday nights are the time to visit East Farmingdale's Piazzetta. This is the evening that the pizzeria offers its regular, Sicilian, and "Grandma" pies for $12.75. No coupon is necessary, and you get the special whether you dine in, do takeout, or order delivery—which is free within a certain area.

Regulars say you can't miss the signature Grandma pie. Shaped in a cheesy rectangle, like the Sicilian pies, these specialty pizzas are flecked with large dollops of marinara sauce between expanses of crispy, golden-brown cheese. You can swing by any night to try the gourmet pizzas by the pie or the slice. Snag a slice of pizza topped with vodka sauce and prosciutto or order an entire pie smothered with marsala chicken and mushrooms. Whatever you choose at Piazzetta, expect it to be crafted fresh, hot, and fast.

CC-BY-2.0/Flickr T.Tseng